SparkChange Carbon Market Monthly Report (January 2024)

February 15, 2024

January Developments:

  • European carbon has made a very weak start to the year, with the EUA price declining by 19.8% over the course of January.
  • The sell-off was most aggressive at the start of the month, with EUAs falling 12% from the year-end price of cEUR 77 to settle at cEUR 63 by Friday, 12th January. Thereafter, the EUA price has largely traded in a relatively tight cEUR 3 range between EUR 60 and EUR 63, albeit prices have dipped below the psychologically important level of EUR 60 on a few occasions.
  • Bearish fundamentals persist on the demand side – low emissions due to sluggish economic output, increased renewable output, and gas displacing coal in the merit order – whilst supply-side headwinds – increased EUA supply from REPowerEU, the inclusion of Maritime emissions – continue to weigh on the fundamental balance. The incremental weakness since the start of the year has been attributed to forecasts for a mild end to the winter, gas prices that have continued to fall, and the activity of investment Funds. Geopolitical flare-ups and events on the Red Sea have added to volatility.
  • ICE Data has shown that Investment Funds built a record net short position in EUA Futures – c40mt – to mid-December 2023. This net short position roughly halved to year-end, likely as a result of risk management over a seasonally volatile period as opposed to a changing fundamental view, but has built back to c33mt over the course of January, adding to the weight of weak compliance demand.

Outlook

  • Despite the stark weakness in the EUA price in the first two weeks of the year, prices have been largely stable in the cEUR 60 – 63 channel since then.
  • Analyst consensus forecasts, updated in year-ahead outlooks, have fallen markedly in the near-term – 2024 EUA price consensus now stands at cEUR 71, 25% down vs. this time a year ago. At the same time, the constructive outlook to 2030 is relatively unchanged, with consensus forecasts pointing to an EUA price of cEUR 140. That conflict between near-term pessimism and longer-term optimism seems to be causing some tension in the EUA price at today’s levels. In that context it’s worth noting that whilst Investment Funds’ positioning in EUA Futures – typically used for shorter duration positions – are increasing, at SparkChange we have seen an increase in units in issue in our ETC of close to 45% since late-November.
  • With no catalyst on the immediate horizon to change currently bearish fundamentals, the EUA price is likely to be rather sentiment-driven, with focus on the near-term triggering fresh downside, and focus on the long-term triggering recoveries. The evolution of the gas price (on fundamental or geopolitical grounds), as well as any surprises in mid-term weather forecasts may add to volatility.

1 Commitment of Traders report published by the Intercontinental Exchange

January 2024
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

DISCLAIMERS
This communication has been provided to you for informational purposes only.

This communication is not intended to constitute, and should not be construed as, investment advice, financial promotion, investment recommendations or investment research.

This communication is not intended as and is not to be taken as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any security or interest, nor does it constitute an offer or solicitation in any jurisdiction, including those in which such an offer or solicitation is not authorised or to any person to whom it is unlawful to make such a solicitation or offer. Distribution of information contained in this communication may be restricted by law. Persons receiving this communication should inform themselves about and observe any such restrictions. Any dissemination or other unauthorised use of this information or documents by any person or entity is strictly prohibited.

SparkChange believes the information in this communication to be correct at the date of issue. However, no representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy of any of the information provided. Some information in this communication is based on information given/obtained from independent research providers that SparkChange considers to be reliable. Analysis provided in this communication may be based on subjective assessments and assumptions and can use one among several alternative methodologies that produce diverse results. Hence, analysis and projections should not be seen as factual and should not be relied upon as accurate predictions of future performance.